A Banquet of Butterflies for Brian, and the Dawn of the Midnight Rambler

English: Grave of Brian Jones of the Rolling S...

English: Grave of Brian Jones of the Rolling Stones, Priory Road Cemetery in Prestbury, Gloucestershire (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

My first bootleg LP, covr of Mick reads Shelley, Hyde Park, July 5, 1969Rising from the butterflies and ashes of Brian's death: the Midnight RamblerLive Confetti: at least a few butterflies survivedPhoto of Mick TAYLOR and ROLLING STONES and Mick JAGGER

For those who couldn’t make (or afford) the Rolling Stones’ return to Hyde Park in London this month after a mere 44-year hiatus, here’s a little something that’s far cheaper, but just might be as long: my review essay for the cool live music blog and website, Collectors Music Reviews (CMR to friends like you), of a just-now-surfacing new bootleg release of the original ’69 concert that turned into a tribute to their founder, Brian Jones. Tragically, Jones had been discovered drowned just two days earlier at the age of 27, a couple of weeks after splitting from the Stones, supposedly successfully battling his various addictions, and reportedly looking forward to new musical ventures with new people. Alas, it would never come to pass. 

So the Hyde Park show (King Crimson, among others, were also on the bill this afternoon) turned into a mass memorial for the past, but a beacon for the future too. As I listened and contemplated this concert (which I’d heard in many incarnations over the years), it struck me as a watershed moment indeed. It was the first-ever show for Brian’s replacement, guitarist Mick Taylor, of course, but there’s more (read to find out! Yes, I am a tease). I’m hoping, given its historical significance, the Stones will open their vaults and release this audio officially someday, as they’ve been doing as of late with official releases (download only) of  seminal shows from their 1973, ’75, ’78, ’81 tours and more (go to www.rollingstones.com for the skinny).  As the song says, you can’t always get what you want, but sometimes you get what you need…and for now, this release is it. (And no, unfortunately, I don’t know where you can get a copy; but as with all things in this Interweb age, you likely won’t have to wait too long until this baby finds its way on a torrent file sharing site, or in the marketplace on eBay). 




Hyde Park Legend 1969 (Complete Edition)

Live At Hyde Park, London, July 5, 1969. CD ONE (66:08): Introduction (by Sam Cutler), Excerpt From Adonais (Eulogy For Brian Jones), I’m Yours and I’m Hers, Jumpin’ Jack Flash, Mercy Mercy, Stray Cat Blues, No Expectations, I’m Free, Down Home Girl, Love In Vain, Loving Cup, Honky Tonk Women, Midnight Rambler, (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction, Street Fighting Man.

CD TWO (67:12): Sympathy For The Devil, Backstage Rehearsal (I’m Yours and I’m Hers), Introduction (Alternate Edit Version), I’m Yours and I’m Hers (Edit Version), (I Can’t Get No) Satisfaction (Edit Version), Sympathy For The Devil (Edit Version), TV News Report, Stones In The Park Radio Special, Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5, Part 6, Sympathy For The Devil (Frost On Saturday TV), You Can’t Always Get What You Want (David Frost Show TV).

Maybe it was Mick’s frilly white frock that captured my imagination (actually, I’m pretty sure it wasn’t). But the Rolling Stones’ July 5, 1969 concert at Hyde Park holds a special place in my heart and head. No, I wasn’t there (I was a mere sprout discovering The Monkees an ocean away) on that sad day of soul searching 44 years ago, when the Stones swooped onto the stage to pay tribute to their fallen founder, Brian Jones, who had died scarcely 48 hours earlier. I wasn’t there to witness the Stones at their most maimed – aside, of course, from the nightmare of Altamont that was to arrive a mere five months later. I wasn’t there to hear the almost desperate grasping-for-meaning amid the stabbing, frequently out-of-tune guitars. I didn’t catch one of Mick Jagger’s dead-on-arrival butterflies from a box, and I didn’t hear his impatient call for silence from the restless crowd as he attempted to eulogize Brian by reading an excerpt from Percy Shelley’s poem, “Adonais.”

I wasn’t there, but after all these years I can still hear that show (and, with my mind’s eye, see the packed-park panorama) vividly, because the Hyde Park concert was the first Stones bootleg LP I ever bought as a teenager, more than 30 years ago. At first glance, it seemed an inauspicious totem. The LP cover consisted of nothing more than a washed-out orange-red Xerox slip sheet featuring a primitive pic of Mick Jagger working the crowd in that frock. The LP inside was no less rudimentary – a blank label save for the hand-stamped logo of some label ludicrously called Wisconsin Cheese Records. And the sound itself? Even cruder than that cover. I was excited and enthralled, instantly in the throes of this new, strange and secret world — of both the Rolling Stones themselves, and the shadowy labels that captured the raw energy of the band as living, breathing magicians of riff and attitude.

What I didn’t fully grasp then, however, was how important a document that record was. Despite the woefully under-rehearsed performance by its headlining principals (yes, there were other bands that played that day), the Hyde Park concert was as historically momentous as the performance itself was not. The show was professionally recorded and filmed, and attended by hundreds of thousands of people – the crowd estimates kept climbing as the hype kept building –  and the event has since passed into rock & roll legend, if not myth. (So much so that tickets for the Stones return to Hyde Park this July for two shows celebrating their 50th anniversary sold out within minutes – and at slightly higher prices, we might add).

As an opening salvo that prefaced their legendary 1969 tour, Hyde Park – which had been planned weeks before Jones’s death (but after his departure from the band that June) – came at a critical juncture in the life of the group. The Stones hadn’t toured as a working unit in three years (which, back then, was an unthinkable stretch of time in the fleeting, fickle world of pop). And in the time since their 1966 U.S. tour, they had been beset by drug raids, work visa problems, and the lukewarm response to ”Their Satanic Majesties Request,” an LP ridiculed as an inferior copycat of the Beatles’ magnum opus, “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band,” right down to its psychedelic garden-party cover.

Miraculously, they had managed to not just bounce, but pounce back with what still might be their best album, “Beggars Banquet,” in the winter of 1968. A mere seven months later, they released the epochal “Let It Bleed” in the summer of ‘69. They had a lot of  new material, a new Wunderkind lead guitarist in Mick Taylor, and a new mission to show both off  to a public hungry for their return. And then Brian Jones, whose creative energy and musical acumen had been emaciated by, ironically, all manner of bloated excess, fulfilled the fatal prophesy those around him feared. On July 3, 1969, the onetime leader of the Rolling Stones was found drowned in his swimming pool at his home at Cotchford Farm, Sussex, an estate once owned by “Winnie-The-Pooh” author A.A. Milne. Shaken but stirred to action, the Stones nevertheless decided the show must go on.

And so too have the recordings of that show gone on, and on. By our accounts, nearly three dozen unofficial/semi-legit and even official versions of the concert – on LP, CD, VHS, DVD, and Blu-Ray – have surfaced and circulated among collectors and historians around the world. There have been some good audio titles by the likes of labels like Living Legend, VGP, and Swingin’ Pig, among others, that have utilized very good mono recordings, stereo soundboards taken from FM radio broadcasts,  and even a Granada television special that aired at the time.

This latest entry, entitled “Hyde Park Legend 1969 (Complete Edition),” is certainly one of the best and, yes, most complete editions of the concert ever assembled in any format. Issued by the increasingly impressive Goldplate label, which recently weighed in with “Double Door Club Gig,” a definitive CD/DVD version of the Stones’ 1997 stand at Chicago’s Double Door (which we recently reviewed for CMR), this two-disc set likewise stands as a solid upgrade to most of what’s out there. Or at least an upgrade to the dozen or so titles we’ve heard since those halcyon Wisconsin Cheese days. And its four-page booklet and tray card of color and black-and-white photographs from the show are a definite improvement over that homemade Xerox.

“Legend” offers the complete 14-song concert in very good, raw-but-clear sound with a couple of caveats (one of the few drawbacks, for example, is a multiple source matrix of “[I Can’t Get No] Satisfaction,” whose various vantage point punch-ins and splices are a bit distracting and off-putting; honestly, we’d rather have one consistently sourced, if muddy, version of the song, but to each her own). But overall, part of the rawness of this Goldplate release has less to do with the quality of the available recordings than the Stones’ own rough sound and rusty performance that day.

Jagger even apologizes, sort of, after the Stones stagger through a lurching “Loving Cup” (a song that would not be properly heard for three years until its release on 1972′s “Exile On Main St.”; here Mick introduces its title at Hyde Park as its oft-booted title, “Gimme A Little Drink” ). “We hope we get better as we go along,” Jagger says late in the set before the lads launch gamely into the then-new single, “Honky Tonk Women,” whose gin-soaked barroom queen was taking Mick upstairs while the tune climbed the charts.

In addition to containing a slew of interesting bonus cuts, disc two rounds out the complete show with the debut public performance of “Sympathy For The Devil,” a scintillating 18-minute finale that Mick introduces as a “samba” replete with Ginger Johnson’s African Drummers and percussionist Rocky Dijon (who plays on the studio track).  Given the gold Stones standards they would become, it’s exhilarating to hear nascent new material like “Sympathy,” “Midnight Rambler,” and “Jumpin’ Jack Flash” – tracks that would come to define the Stones’ identity and make their live legend – played in front of an audience for the very first time. “Midnight Rambler,” especially, is a treat to behold, as Jagger introduces the song as something new “you haven’t heard before.”

Already at this early stage, we hear that “Rambler” has been radically reworked and  reconstituted, morphing from its beginnings as an insular, claustrophobic studio track into a heavier, sprawling thing of stealth and beauty. The guitars growl like crouching tigers that lunge with claws out, while Mick prances, preens, and plays cat and mouse with melody, rhythm, and his bleating stabs of harmonica. Just like that, the faux James Brown shuffles and Otis Redding pleading microphone moves are no more.

“Didja hear about the Midnight Rambluh?” Mick queries the unsuspecting throng. Well, here I am. This track may represent the very moment (along with the ”Jumpin’ Jack Flash” promotional video) that rock’s quintessential frontman first fully inhabits the stage personae he would alternately refine, dilute, and exaggerate throughout the ‘70s and beyond. Thankfully, as presented on “Legend,” the sound is quite good, full, and robust for the duration of this watershed moment.

Also interesting on “Legend” is hearing the Stones limbering up with early, Brian-era works like Don Covay’s “Mercy Mercy” and Alvin Robinson’s “Down Home Girl” with their still mint condition new guitarist, Mick Taylor (his first public appearance on stage with the band) in tow. Though Taylor, like the rest of the band, is heard still finding his footing and figuring out his role as Keith Richards’ new foil, he turns in a lovely and sure-handed slide guitar solo on the tragically underheard “No Expectations” – whose pathos takes on added dimension of poignancy given the circumstances of the previous days. We also hear the premiere of Robert Johnson’s “Love In Vain,” which would soon become a Stones tour staple and blues showpiece for Mick and “little” Mick.  Disc two includes sounds of the Stones backstage rehearsing their opening number, Johnny Winter’s “I’m Yours and I’m Hers” – reportedly one of Brian’s recent favorite tunes – as an uncredited narrator describes Taylor as their “nervous” new guitarist.

There are also a handful of alternate edit versions of songs on disc two that, to our ears, do not sound dramatically different from what we hear on the first disc (but warrant further inspection), plus we also get a vintage TV news report on the concert. The real bonus here, from an archeological standpoint, though, is the inclusion of a brief  but incisive six-segment radio special that carries commentary and interviews from the festival’s organizers and observers. Though the source of the special is uncredited, a BBC program is probably not too terrible a guess.

But wait, there’s more! A pair of David Frost television appearance selections – the aforementioned “Sympathy” and “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” (which the Stones were then promoting as the B-side to the new “Honky Tonk Women” single released that month) – are presented in their truncated-for-TV form. Both tracks feature live vocals from Mick and canned instrumental backing tracks, which was customary for the time. In addition to having excellent sound, these era-appropriate addendums make for nice time capsule mementos.

So too is this set from Goldplate a nice memento and valuable keepsake of a bygone time and pivotal moment in the band’s history. Although we can’t help but wonder why, given all of the video footage of Hyde Park available from both legitimate and nefarious sources, that a simple DVD of the show was not included – especially given the “complete edition” tag in the title, and Goldplate’s admirably comprehensive CD/DVD treatment of the Stones ‘97 “Double Door Gig.”  The Frost TV appearances would have been nice too. But still, given those early Wisconsin Cheese days of faded photos and muffled audio, “Legend” is akin to a fresh white frock – and has a lot more life than those poor butterflies.

Watch and listen to the Stones’ perform “Sympathy For The Devil” and “Midnight Rambler” (a nice snippet in HD) for the first time at Hyde Park, July 5, 1969 here:



And lastly, check out this really nicely shot fan footage of my favorite Stones lead guitarist, Mick Taylor, on stage with the “boys” this month, a mere 44 years after his debut show with the group, to join ’em on “Midnight Rambler.” MT solo at the three-minute mark for those who can’t wait! Watch it here:






  1. Just came over to let you know you have a brand new fan! Reading one post on your website got me obsessed without delay. Really, you are awesome!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks so much for your kind words, and glad you liked the post and are enjoying the site! I just officially launched “RPM” last weekend so you are one of the very first (besides folks who know me from my print/published writing over the years) to drop by and check out the site, which will continue to grow and expand with this liftoff. I’m always adding fresh content and some good reads and entertaining stuff for discerning music fans from my vast story archives. If you’re interested, you can go to the “Liner Notes” (About Me) section of my home page menu, which will tell you a bit of what I’ve been up to, and will be up to here. Welcome and glad to have you aboard! One question: still getting the hang of this format and just curious how you found me (Facebook? links? Google? Stones site search?)


  2. oldschool · · Reply

    Enjoyed your review on CMR but to your desire for this show to be officially released by the Stones this would have to be done with ATCO as Allen Klein (RIP) owns the rights to all Stones music written before 1971 I believe. This may be the reason the archive shows start with the famous 1973. I would love to see this officially released along with a complete show from 1969 but don’t know if we will ever get to hear these shows from the master tapes.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for reading, appreciate the feedback too! Good points. As I understand it, yes, Allen Klein had owned the rights to the publishing catalog of songs recorded in the studio prior to 1971 (hence the legendary 1972 tour — which Jagger wanted to release as a live album — have remained in the can, because of the inclusion of Abko-owned songs like YCAGWYW, which Jagger has publicly said in interviews in some ways tops the original….although the Eagle Rock Entertainment folks have released a soundtrack to the recently released film, maybe semi-legit not sure). The hit-and-miss ’77 LP, “Love You Live,” did contain some pre-71 songs, so that clouds the issue for sure. I know a big deal was made when “40 Licks” and “Grrr” were released because it represented the merging/partnership of the pre-1971 Abko/Glimmer Twins studio catalog for the first time. The Stones may get to Hyde Park yet. But there are perhaps other pressing shows (Brussels/LA Friday) that they wanted to deal with first — and, frankly, the historical import of Hyde Park certainly exceeds the quality of the performance. BTW, Yes, I so share your desire for a legit soundboard complete concert from ’69, like the New York/Baltimore shows that made up ‘Ya Ya’s.’ Good complete boot versions exist, naturally, but to hear a professional mix etc. really needs to happen at this point. It is an essential piece of Stones history. Fingers crossed. Thanks again for reading and taking the time to comment.


  3. Reblogged this on RPM: Jonathan Perry's Life in Analog and commented:

    It was 46 years ago today that Rolling Stones founder and early leader Brian Jones was found at the bottom of his swimming pool on July 3, 1969. Here’s my meditation (in the guise of a CD review) on what the Stones had become in the year or two leading up to that fateful day; and what they were on the verge of becoming — a reinvention borne of both necessity and evolution — without him.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


Writings by (and about) Greil Marcus


A music blog. rock. punk. garage. power pop. vinyl. cd. dvd. bluray. books.

The Department of Tangents

Conversations About Comedy, Music, and Horror ETC

The Baseball Bloggess

Loves the 4-6-3 and the Serial Comma.

Let there be Elvis

Just another story for the great heap

Coco Crisp's Afro

A baseball publication that embraces the absurdity of life, the 8-1 putout, and the history of the OAKLAND Athletics (cococrispafro@gmail.com)

Interesting Literature

A Library of Literary Interestingness


A topnotch WordPress.com site

Cardboard Gods

Voice of the Mathematically Eliminated

interrupting my train of thought

a website about a book by phil dellio

%d bloggers like this: